Home | TheWaterBlog

TheWaterBlog: If you want to share unique images and observations in this section, or would like to know about syndicating these posts, send an email to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.!

 

posted by Frank van Steenbergen
April 22, 2013

With the large and sometimes overexposed attention for land grabbing in Africa, good examples tend to be forgotten. Here is a picture of an inspection team to a land concession issued five years earlier.

The land is in a remote part of Amhara state in Ethiopia. It is barren and windswept. The concession was given to an investor from the ‘diaspora’ community- i.e. Ethiopians who spent part of their life abroad and are often a source of investment.  In the last five years he has, with moderate success, been trying to cultivate sorghum and ‘teff’ (the nutritious grass crop) on the thin soils. Part of the land concession was the obligation to protect the land and undertake catchment measures.

Here is the inspection team, consisting of representatives of several zonal offices (Agriculture, Investment, Environment), making an unannounced visit – checking whether the promises that were part of the concession have been kept. They were not: the investor admitted that he had not yet undertaken land protection measures. The issue would be settled amicably and without any pressure or back payment. The investor will make a land management plan and implement it. So this would be a very normal small event – how things ought to be and often are.

There is a bigger side to this small event.  Things like this do not appear in the news and are not highlighted. What is highlighted are all things wrong or framed to be wrong. While it is good that there are watchdogs, some bark whenever and one gets the feeling that they are like mastiffs let loose. It is good to be critical, but good to be positive as well and not automatically damage a country’s reputation.

Of late, I have been reading a report called ‘Diagnosing Corruption in Ethiopia:  Perceptions, Realities and The Ways Forwards for Key Sectors’. If you read the title it suggests there is much amiss, yet if you read the content there is the normal and healthy worry but also the observation that Ethiopia does much better than other countries. The question of course is why that message does not make it to the cover.

There is a section in this book on corruption in land management. The report, commissioned by World Bank and the Federal Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (FEACC), finds that corruption risks in land management in Ethiopia are increasing because of a weak policy and regulatory framework on land allocation, titling, and management. This gives scope for lots of local mishaps. In spite of this, there are other things that go well, such as land inspections like the one described above.

This raises another issue related tp land grabs. Often it is portrayed in conspiracy terms: of a new form of colonialism driven by newly emerging and natural resource constrained powers, trying to secure the world’s last land frontiers. However, what I observed first hand is another problem. What is often forgotten is the clumsy and dangerous opportunism in land grabs.  This can be a market businessmen in Addis getting hold of several 1000’s hectares of land in a remote part of Ethiopia without having a basic clue on how to farm, or Spanish building contractors in Mauretania in the same league, trying find another pursuit with the construction industry in doldrums.  Such opportunism does not necessarily create an unbalanced world, because these are the land grabs that fail. However they do much damage because in the course of the ill-planned adventures they forest, land and water resources in some still-pristine areas gets destroyed. In line with the recommendation of the ‘Diagnosing’ report, what is required is a better managed and better planned development of land, not a polarization of the issue.

  • Pocket paradises

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen April 01, 2013Cities grow and there is nothing stopping them. In 2050 not half but 65% of global citizens may be urbanites.As our life becomes more urban, it becomes faster, richer, more diverse but also impersonal (how many neighbours do know us?), grim, impersonal, dangerous, insecure.There is much to learn from the oldest megacities: how to avoid grime and what ...

    Read more

  • The Coming Plastic Revolution

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen March 04, 2013Is this the next revolution in agriculture and water management: plastic mulch?In rural China, entire landscapes have already been transformed by ultra-thin poly-ethylene plastic foils. They are laid out in long glistening strips, one next to the other. The total area under plastic mulch in China is enormous. One estimate  (Kasirajan & Ngouajio, ...

    Read more

  • Towards a Lighter Burden: A Small Step

    March 09, 2013Square, unwieldy and (often) yellow, jerry cans are a common sight in rural areas across the world. They were originally designed to contain fuel/cooking oil, and are probably quite suitable for that purpose. Ergonomically, they are perhaps least suited to fetching water from a public source and carrying it over long distances. Unfortunately, this is what precisely what rural communi...

    Read more

  • Freak Climate Changes

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen March 04, 2013While we ponder on long term climate change, and on what the middle of this century will look like if the earth has further heated up and some climatic cycles are upset, there is another thing to think about: freak, unexplained climate changes not linked to any clear trend but important nonetheless.A main example of an unexplained change is the rise o...

    Read more

  • On Water User Associations (WUAs)

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen, courtesy Rajeshwar Mishra February 25, 2013They were sometimes created by the stroke of a pen – but also perished by it: Water Users Associations or WUAS.  For instance, in the Gezira system in Sudan – Africa’s largest irrigation system - a several years-long effort to reform the irrigation system with World Bank support came to an abrupt end last year with...

    Read more

  • Cactus, the Arid Miracle

    posted by Ahmed Albakri, Bothinah Albakri, Sharafuddin A. Saleh and Frank van Steenbergen February 18, 2013Cactus is a miracle plant.  It grows in arid areas where no other fruit ‘fears to tread.’ During the most severe droughts, the dried pads are the lifeline of cattle that have no other means of support. Cactus is a regular feature in dry areas, from Mexico to Morocco.For a long time the ...

    Read more

  • alt

    The World We Want: Governing & Managing Water Resources for Sustainable Development

    posted by Joakim Harlin, UNDP February 11, 2013 The pressures on water resources that more and more countries are experiencing will undoubtedly increase by 2030. Insufficient access to water resources is often not driven by water scarcity, but by ineffective and fragmented institutions, management systems and investments and insufficient human capacities. The ability of countries to alloc...

    Read more

  • Moon Water

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen February 4, 2013In the nineteenth century, as white farmers moved up north in what is now South Africa, the original ‘Bushmen’ inhabitants of this area were chased out and hunted. They were marginalized and slowly their culture practically disappeared.  Some groups like the /Xam completely vanished, only leaving behind a heritage of rock paintings (see image: c...

    Read more

  • Use of rock dust in bio- fertilizers.

    posted by Ruben Borge January 28, 2013The Usambara Cooperative Union (UCU) in Tanzania is proud of their fair trade certified organic coffee. For more than forty years, returns from this crop allowed farmers to pay the bills of their children’s education. It has always been cultivated without chemical fertilizers or pesticides, but also without any fertilization.  After four decades of continue...

    Read more

  • The Power of Dew

    posted by Frank van Steenbergen January 21, 2013Even as surface water is overcommitted and even new groundwater resources get scarce, one major frontier of water remains untapped: water from the atmosphere or, to be more poetic, dew.Dew is formed when the temperature of air with a certain moisture level cools below a certain temperature. The air becomes too cold to carry all this moisture and dew ...

    Read more